The short version: Returns: CAGR and XIRR and Alpha, Beta and Sharpe

Most people judge funds by one number: last year's return. That is the worst way. Here is a better way.

Types of returns

  • Absolute return: total gain over a period. Good for under a year.
  • CAGR: yearly growth rate for a lumpsum held over more than a year.
  • XIRR: yearly return for SIPs and irregular cash flows.
  • Trailing returns: returns up to today over 1, 3, 5 or 10 years. These change every day.
  • Calendar-year returns: returns for each year, such as 2022 or 2023. They show how the fund behaved in different market phases.
  • Rolling returns: returns over every possible window of a fixed length, such as every 3-year period in the last 10 years.

Why rolling returns are better

Trailing returns depend on today's date. A fund that had a great last six months can show an excellent 1-year figure that has nothing to do with long-term skill.

Rolling returns ask: "If I had invested on any day, what would I have got after 3 years?" and repeat that for every day. You then see:

  • The average return.
  • The worst return.
  • How often the fund beat its benchmark.

Example. Fund A beat its benchmark in 75 out of 100 rolling 3-year periods and its worst 3-year return was 4% a year. Fund B beat its benchmark in 45 of 100 periods and its worst was −3% a year. Fund A looks more consistent.

The right benchmark

A fund should be compared to an index that matches its style.

  • A large cap fund against a large cap index.
  • A mid cap fund against a mid cap index.
  • A debt fund against a matching debt index.

SEBI requires funds to use the Total Return Index (TRI), which includes dividends. Comparing against a price-only index makes the fund look better than it is.

Compare with peers

Also compare against funds in the same category. A mid cap fund that returns 15% in a year when the average mid cap fund returned 22% is lagging, even if 15% sounds good.

Judging risk as well as return

MeasureWhat it tells you
Standard deviationSize of swings
Maximum drawdownWorst fall from a peak
Recovery timeHow long it took to get back to the old peak
Sharpe ratioReturn per unit of total risk
Sortino ratioReturn per unit of downside risk
BetaSensitivity to the market
Up capture / down captureShare of market rises and falls that the fund took

A good active fund often has down capture below 100% (falls less than the market) with up capture close to or above 100%.

Worked example

Two mid cap funds.

1-year3-year (yearly)5-year (yearly)Worst fall
Fund A42%15%13%−38%
Fund B20%16%15%−29%

Fund A shines on the 1-year number, but over 3 and 5 years Fund B is ahead and fell less in the worst phase. Fund B looks stronger.

Traps to avoid

  • Recency trap. Choosing a fund because of the last 1 year.
  • Survivorship bias. Funds that did badly are often merged or closed, so the survivors look better.
  • Star manager trap. The manager who delivered the returns may have left.
  • Benchmark games. A fund compared to an easy benchmark.
  • Start-date games. A chart that starts at a market low.
  • Mixing lumpsum and SIP returns. CAGR and XIRR are not comparable.

Understanding where returns came from

Performance attribution splits a fund's return into:

  • Stock selection: picking winners.
  • Sector allocation: over or under-weighting sectors.
  • Cash and timing.

If a fund's outperformance came from one big bet that worked once, it may not repeat.

A simple scorecard

For each shortlisted fund, note:

  • Rolling 3-year and 5-year return vs benchmark and peers
  • Worst fall and recovery time
  • Down capture
  • Manager tenure and process
  • Expense ratio
  • Fit with your portfolio

The best fund is the one that scores well on most, not the one that tops one chart.

Common mistakes

  • Reviewing every month and switching on short-term results.
  • Comparing a debt fund's 1-year return with an equity fund's.
  • Ignoring costs when comparing returns.

Questions people ask

How long should I wait before judging a fund? At least 3 years, ideally through a full market cycle.

Is a fund that beats the index every year better? Rarely does any fund do that. Look at consistency over rolling periods.

Takeaways

  • Rolling returns and risk measures beat a single return number.
  • Use the right benchmark and compare with peers.
  • Look for steady results, not a lucky year.

Next deep dive: Mutual Fund Tax in Depth

Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. This page is for education and is not investment advice.