The short version: PMS, AIF and SIF

These products sit above mutual funds. They are meant for larger investments. They allow the manager more freedom. They also bring higher minimums, less liquidity and often higher costs.

PMS (Portfolio Management Services)

What it is. A portfolio manager builds a portfolio of securities for you in your own demat account. You own the shares directly. Regulated under SEBI's Portfolio Managers Regulations, 2020.

Minimum. ₹50 lakh per client, with lower limits possible for accredited investors under SEBI's framework.

Types

  • Discretionary: the manager decides and trades.
  • Non-discretionary: the manager suggests, you approve each trade.
  • Advisory: the manager only advises. You or your broker execute.

Typical features

  • Often 15 to 35 stocks. Concentrated portfolios.
  • A customised portfolio possible.
  • Entry and exit usually quicker than AIFs, though some have exit loads.

Fee models

  • Fixed fee: a percentage of assets, commonly about 2% to 2.5%.
  • Performance fee: a percentage of profits above a hurdle.
  • Hybrid: a lower fixed fee plus a performance fee.

Example of a hybrid fee. You invest ₹1 crore. The fee is 1% fixed plus 20% of returns above a 10% hurdle. The portfolio earns 15% (₹15 lakh). Fixed fee: ₹1 lakh. Profit above hurdle: ₹5 lakh. Performance fee: 20% of ₹5 lakh = ₹1 lakh. Total fee: ₹2 lakh, or 2% of your investment. Fee structures differ. Ask for the exact formula, including whether a high-water mark applies.

Tax. Each sale is a taxable event in your hands, as capital gains. A manager who trades a lot creates more tax than a mutual fund would, because inside a mutual fund, trades are not taxed to you.

Comparing PMS performance. Ask for audited, time-weighted returns, across more than one market cycle, and compare them with an index fund and with a mutual fund doing a similar job.

AIF (Alternative Investment Fund)

What it is. A privately pooled fund under SEBI's AIF Regulations, 2012.

Minimum. ₹1 crore per investor, with lower limits for some categories of people.

Categories

CategoryWhat it coversNotes
Category IVenture capital, startups, SME, social ventures, infrastructureSeen as socially or economically useful
Category IIPrivate equity, private credit and debt funds, funds of fundsNo leverage beyond limited borrowing for day-to-day needs
Category IIIHedge-fund-style strategies, long-short, derivativesCan use leverage

How AIFs are structured

  • Often closed-ended for 3 to 7 years or more.
  • Capital calls: you commit ₹1 crore, but the manager draws the money in instalments, say 30%, 40% and 30%.
  • J-curve: early years can show negative returns because of fees, with gains arriving later.
  • Fees: a management fee (commonly about 1.5% to 2.5% a year) plus a share of profits above a hurdle (commonly 20% above 10% to 12%).

Tax. Category I and II funds are generally pass-through, meaning the income is taxed in the investor's hands. Category III funds are generally taxed at the fund level. This differs by fund, so confirm with a tax professional.

Risks. Illiquidity, valuation that is hard to check, concentration, leverage and manager risk.

SIF (Specialized Investment Fund)

What it is. A framework from SEBI, in force from 1 April 2025, that sits between mutual funds and PMS or AIFs. SIFs are offered by mutual fund houses under mutual fund regulations.

Minimum. ₹10 lakh per investor, counted across a fund house's SIF strategies.

What is different. SIF strategies can take limited short positions using derivatives, within stated limits. That allows long-short strategies not available in regular mutual funds.

Examples of strategies. Equity long-short, equity ex-top-100 long-short, sector rotation long-short and debt long-short, among others as approved.

How you hold it. As units, like a mutual fund. Redemption frequency depends on the strategy. Read the scheme documents.

Tax. Follows mutual fund tax rules based on what the strategy holds. Check each strategy's category.

Who it suits. Investors who already hold a good core of mutual funds, can handle ups and downs, and want a different return pattern.

Side by side

Mutual FundSIFPMSAIF
RegulatorSEBISEBISEBISEBI
Min. ticket₹100–₹500₹10 lakh₹50 lakh₹1 crore
OwnershipUnitsUnitsShares in your dematUnits in a pooled fund
Short sellingNot as strategyLimitedDependsYes, in Cat III
LiquidityDailyPer strategyFlexible, with possible loadOften locked
TaxedOn saleOn saleOn each tradeDepends
DisclosureVery highHighClient reportsVaries

Ten questions before you invest

  • Is the manager registered with SEBI? (Check the registration number.)
  • What is the long-term, audited track record?
  • How does it compare to a mutual fund or index doing something similar?
  • What are the all-in costs, including management, performance and other fees?
  • What is the lock-in, and what are the exit terms?
  • How concentrated is the portfolio?
  • Does it use leverage or derivatives?
  • How much of the manager's own money is invested?
  • How will this be taxed for me?
  • What share of my net worth would this be? Keep it small.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming a higher minimum means better returns.
  • Not reading the risk factors.
  • Putting too large a share of net worth in an illiquid product.
  • Buying because of a friend's tip or a flashy track record.

Takeaways

  • PMS, AIF and SIF give managers more freedom, with more risk and cost.
  • Check tax, lock-in and all-in cost before you invest.
  • Keep them a small slice of your wealth.

Next deep dive: Market Cycles and Investor Behaviour

Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. This page is for education and is not investment advice.