The short version: SIP vs Lumpsum

How a SIP actually works

  • You choose a fund, an amount and a date.
  • You authorise your bank to debit that amount every month. This is a mandate, set up through NACH or UPI AutoPay.
  • On the SIP date, the money moves to the fund. Units are allotted at that day's NAV (or the next business day's, if the date is a holiday).
  • You see the units in your folio.

UPI AutoPay limits are generally high enough for mutual fund SIPs, typically up to ₹1 lakh per instalment. Check your bank.

SIP options

  • Regular SIP: the same amount, same date, every month.
  • Step-up (top-up) SIP: the amount rises by a set percentage or amount each year.
  • Perpetual SIP: no end date. It runs until you stop it.
  • Fixed-tenure SIP: ends on a date you choose.
  • Weekly, fortnightly, quarterly: offered by many funds.
  • Pause: many fund houses let you pause a SIP for a few months.

What a ₹10,000 monthly SIP can grow to

These are illustrations at fixed assumed returns. Real markets do not move in straight lines.

YearsAmount investedAt 8% a yearAt 10% a yearAt 12% a year
10₹12 lakh₹18.3 lakh₹20.5 lakh₹23.0 lakh
15₹18 lakh₹34.6 lakh₹41.4 lakh₹50.0 lakh
20₹24 lakh₹58.9 lakh₹75.9 lakh₹98.9 lakh
25₹30 lakh₹95.1 lakh₹1.33 crore₹1.88 crore

Look at how the last few years do the heavy lifting. Between year 20 and year 25 at 12%, the corpus nearly doubles.

SIP in a falling market, shown

You invest ₹10,000 a month for 6 months. The NAV goes 100, 90, 80, 70, 80, 90.

  • Units bought: 100 + 111.1 + 125 + 142.9 + 125 + 111.1 = about 715 units.
  • You invested ₹60,000.
  • At the last NAV of ₹90, your units are worth about ₹64,350.

The NAV ended 10% below where it started, yet the SIP investor is up about 7%. This is what buying more units at lower prices does.

Rising market

In a steadily rising market, SIP units are bought at ever higher prices. A lumpsum at the start would have done better. SIP works best in volatile or uncertain markets, and it protects you from bad timing.

Step-up SIP: why it matters

Start at ₹10,000 a month and raise it by 10% every year. After 20 years at an assumed 12%, you invest much more over time, but you also earn far more. Your income grows, so your SIP should too. Most people can set the step-up percentage when they start.

Tax on SIPs

  • Each instalment is a separate purchase with its own date.
  • When you redeem, the oldest units are sold first (FIFO).
  • Exit load may apply to each instalment if you redeem too soon.
  • Equity: an instalment held over 12 months is long-term. An instalment held for less is short-term.

When a SIP fails

A SIP can fail if your account has too little balance or the mandate has a problem. Typically, no units are bought that month. After a few repeated failures, the fund house may cancel the SIP. Bank charges may apply. Keep a cushion in the account on the SIP date.

SIP vs recurring deposit

SIPRecurring deposit
ReturnMarket-linkedFixed
RiskCan fallLow
TaxOn sale, at capital gains ratesInterest taxed yearly at slab rate
Best forLong goalsShort, fixed goals

How many SIPs?

One SIP per goal is a clean way to think. For example: one for retirement, one for the child's education, one for the home down payment. Each SIP can use one or two funds. Keep the total number of funds between 3 and 6.

When to stop or reduce a SIP

  • Your goal is reached or is within 3 years and you are moving to safer funds.
  • You face a real cash emergency and have no other cushion.
  • A fund has performed poorly for 2 to 3 years against peers and the benchmark.

A market fall is not a reason to stop.

Common mistakes

  • Stopping the SIP in a market fall.
  • Starting too many SIPs without a plan.
  • Never increasing the SIP amount.
  • Choosing a SIP date right after salary day, but forgetting the bank balance dips later in the month.
  • Chasing the fund that gave the best last-year return.

Questions people ask

Is it better to invest on a fixed date? The date matters little over many years. Pick one that suits your cash flow.

Can I do a SIP in a debt fund? Yes.

Can I withdraw any month? Yes, subject to exit load and tax.

Takeaways

  • A SIP builds wealth through discipline and time.
  • The last years do the heavy lifting, so do not stop.
  • Step up your SIP as your income grows.

Next deep dive: Lumpsum, STP and SWP in Practice

Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. This page is for education and is not investment advice.