The short version: Index Funds and ETFs
What an index is
An index is a basket of shares with a formula. The Nifty 50 holds 50 large companies on the NSE. The Sensex holds 30 large companies on the BSE. Index providers decide which companies enter and leave, usually every six months.
Most Indian indices are free-float market-cap weighted. Bigger companies (by the value of shares available to the public) get bigger weights. So a few big companies can dominate.
Index funds and ETFs
Both copy an index.
| Index fund | ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| How you buy | From the fund house or a platform | On the stock exchange through a broker |
| Demat needed | No | Yes |
| Price you pay | End-of-day NAV | Live market price |
| SIP | Easy | Usually manual, some brokers allow it |
| Costs | Expense ratio | Expense ratio plus brokerage and a bid-ask gap |
| Best for | Most beginners | Investors comfortable with trading platforms |
Key quality measures
- Tracking difference: the fund's return minus the index's return over a period. Ideally small and close to the expense ratio.
- Tracking error: how much the daily gap varies. Lower is better.
- Expense ratio: lower is better, but check tracking too.
- Fund size and liquidity (for ETFs): low trading volume means wider gaps between buy and sell prices.
How to buy an ETF, step by step
- Open a demat and trading account.
- Search for the ETF by name.
- Check its volume and the gap between buy and sell prices.
- Compare the live price with its iNAV (indicative NAV), which is shown during the day.
- Use a limit order at a price you accept, not a market order.
- Hold it in your demat account like any share.
The index family
- Broad large-cap: Nifty 50, Sensex, Nifty Next 50.
- Mid and small cap: Nifty Midcap 150, Nifty Smallcap 250.
- Whole-market: broader indices that cover large, mid and small.
- Sector and thematic: banks, IT, pharma and more.
- Debt index funds: target maturity funds, G-Sec and corporate bond indices.
- Gold and silver ETFs.
- International: funds and ETFs tracking global indices, subject to industry limits.
Smart beta (factor) funds
These track indices built on a rule instead of size. Common rules:
- Low volatility: picks shares that have swung less.
- Quality: picks companies with strong profits and low debt.
- Momentum: picks shares that have been rising.
- Value: picks shares that look cheap.
- Equal weight: gives every company the same weight, so smaller companies count more.
They are passive in how they run but they make a style bet. A momentum fund can lag badly when trends reverse. Treat them as satellites on top of a plain index core.
Tax
- Equity index funds and ETFs are taxed as equity funds.
- Debt index funds and target maturity funds are taxed as debt funds.
- Gold ETFs and international index funds follow the rules in Tax on Mutual Funds.
Worked example
Two Nifty 50 index funds. Fund A charges 0.20% and Fund B charges 0.60%. Both invest in the same 50 stocks. Over 20 years on a ₹10,000 monthly SIP at a 12% market return, Fund A could build roughly ₹96 lakh and Fund B roughly ₹91 lakh. Same index, different costs, about ₹5 lakh apart.
Pros and cons
Pros: low cost, simple, no manager risk, good for the core. Cons: no chance to beat the market, you fall with the index, big companies dominate, and some indices are concentrated in a few sectors.
Common mistakes
- Choosing the lowest-cost fund without checking tracking difference.
- Buying a thinly traded ETF with a wide price gap.
- Using a market order for ETFs.
- Piling into factor funds after they have already had a great year.
Questions people ask
Is an index fund the safest equity option? No. It carries full market risk.
Index fund or ETF for a SIP? Index funds are simpler for most people.
Takeaways
- Index funds and ETFs copy an index at low cost.
- Compare tracking difference, not only expense ratio.
- Use smart beta as a small satellite.
Next deep dive: SIP Mastery
Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. This page is for education and is not investment advice.